UPDATE: Murder Trial Begins For Alleged Christmas Day Killer - NBC Right Now/KNDO/KNDU Tri-Cities, Yakima, WA |

Murder Trial Begins For Alleged Christmas Day Killer; Victim's Father Escorted Out Of Courtroom

Posted: Updated:

COEUR d' ALENE, Idaho - Opening statements began early Wednesday in the trial of Joseph Herrera. Herrera is accused of shooting and killing his then girlfriend 18-year-old Stefanie Comack. It happened Christmas morning 2011 in St. Maries Idaho. Joseph Herrera is on trial facing 2nd degree murder charges.

In opening statements Herrera's defense attorney argued that this is not a murder case rather it's an involuntary manslaughter case at best. He says Herrera admits to shooting Comack but it was an accident and not intentional. His attorney says that during an argument Herrera put what he believed to be an unloaded gun to his own head. When Comack tried to grab it away that's when the gun went off.

During opening statements Wednesday the jury was shown a chest camera video taken by a first responding deputy. In the video you can hear family members screaming "Oh my god, oh my god! Stefanie was shot!" Jim Comack, Stefanie's father, was in the courtroom watching the video when he began yelling profanities. As he stood up several armed deputies had to forcefully escort him out of the courtroom.

Because of the outburst the jury also had to leave the courtroom and the trial had to take a short break. Judge Fred Gibler ruled that Jim Comack could no longer be present in the courtroom during the trial.

The trial was recently moved to Kootenai County. Of a jury pool of about 100 people in St. Maries Idaho the prosecution and the defense could not seat a jury in Benewah County because it was a "high profile"case.

  • Top Stories from KHQTop StoriesMore>>

  • Overcrowding issues

    Overcrowding issues

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 12:22 AM EDT2014-08-20 04:22:25 GMT
    It's an issue many counties are dealing with, overcrowding in the jails. And it's an issue the Kootenai county commissioners say they've been trying to correct over the years with bond elections. "we have a chronic problem with overcrowding. In 2013, we spent more than 900 thousand dollars to send inmates out of county to find housing," said county commissioner Dan Green.  More >>
    It's an issue many counties are dealing with, overcrowding in the jails. And it's an issue the Kootenai county commissioners say they've been trying to correct over the years with bond elections. "we have a chronic problem with overcrowding. In 2013, we spent more than 900 thousand dollars to send inmates out of county to find housing," said county commissioner Dan Green.  More >>
  • Owl flies into 10th story apartment, kills canary

    Owl flies into 10th story apartment, kills canary

    Tuesday, August 19 2014 10:03 PM EDT2014-08-20 02:03:02 GMT
    COEUR D'ALENE, Idaho - A Coeur d'Alene couple says an owl flew into their 10th story apartment, opened up their bird cage, and killed one of their canaries.More >>
    COEUR D'ALENE, Idaho - A Coeur d'Alene couple says an owl flew into their 10th story apartment, opened up their bird cage, and killed one of their canaries. The owner told local media that she woke up on Sunday and found bird droppings and feathers all over her apartment. She said she also saw a 6-to-8 inch owl behind a chest of drawers. More >>
  • Liberty Lake residents angered by McMorris Rodgers mailer

    Liberty Lake residents angered by McMorris Rodgers mailer

    Tuesday, August 19 2014 9:27 PM EDT2014-08-20 01:27:15 GMT
    LIBERTY LAKE, Wash. - Two Liberty Lake residents are upset with Congresswoman Cathy McMorris Rodgers after they received a mailer about senior healthcare cutbacks that prominently featured a photograph of a deceased friend. More >>
    LIBERTY LAKE, Wash. - Two Liberty Lake residents are upset with Congresswoman Cathy McMorris Rodgers after they received a mailer about senior healthcare cutbacks that prominently featured a photograph of a deceased friend. Tim and Bette Brattebo received the mailer last week, which shows Maxine Davidson, a friend of theirs that passed away in January 2013. 
    More >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KHQ. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.