Motion Filed To Allow Clay Starbuck To See His Three Young Kids - NBC Right Now/KNDO/KNDU Tri-Cities, Yakima, WA |

Motion Filed To Allow Clay Starbuck To See His Three Young Kids

Posted: Updated:

SPOKANE, Wash. – Clay Starbuck's defense attorneys filed a motion Wednesday at the Spokane County Courthouse asking the judge to drop the no-contact order between Starbuck and his three youngest children that was upheld at his sentencing last week.

"The law does not allow for that," defense attorney Derek Reid told KHQ, adding that it would only make sense if the three children were victims of the crime in a legal sense, which they are not.

Starbuck was convicted in the 2011 murder of his ex-wife, Chanin Starbuck, in June and was sentenced to life in prison without parole last Thursday.

Throughout the course of the trial, Starbuck wasn't allowed to have contact with any of his five children, because they were called as witnesses in the case by the state.  However, that order was lifted for his two adult children when he was convicted.

Reid says they understood the order would also be lifted for the three younger children at Starbuck's sentencing; however, the state asked to uphold it and the judge agreed.

Throughout the sentencing, Clay Starbuck remained calm – except on this one issue.

"[The prosecutor] surprised us today," he told the court.  "We've been expecting the three minor children to be able to visit with me and now in the 11th hour people are trying to make a run to stop that, so I hope you'll take that into consideration."

The motion filed Wednesday says the no-contact order "interferes with Mr. Starbuck's fundamental right to parent," and goes on to say the issue is not the business of a sentencing court, but rather a "family and juvenile court" to decide.

It also cites other case law in which people convicted of crimes have been allowed to see their children, including Mary Kay Letourneau, the Burien, Washington, teacher who was convicted of rape after having a sexual relationship with her 12-year-old student.

"I did prepare several pages to speak about today but this is not the time or place to debate these issues," Clay Starbuck said at his sentencing.  "We're looking forward to a successful appeal and being able to get all the pertinent evidence admitted into court in a fair trial."

That appeal should be filed in the next week or two.  Then, it will be up to a Court of Appeals to decide whether Starbuck's murder conviction stands, or if an error was made during the proceedings that impacted his right to a fair trial, in which case he'd get a new trial.

HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Door-to-door solicitor uses racial slur against Spokane woman

    Door-to-door solicitor uses racial slur against Spokane woman

    Sunday, July 23 2017 9:39 PM EDT2017-07-24 01:39:11 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - One Spokane couple is furious after they say someone who went door-to-door asking for donations used a racial slur against them. Roger and Christina Wink were at home when they heard a knock at the door. Christina answered, and a man described to be in his 20s said he was collecting money to send care packages to active military.

    More >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - One Spokane couple is furious after they say someone who went door-to-door asking for donations used a racial slur against them. Roger and Christina Wink were at home when they heard a knock at the door. Christina answered, and a man described to be in his 20s said he was collecting money to send care packages to active military.

    More >>
  • Highway 95 reopens in Bonner County following crash

    Highway 95 reopens in Bonner County following crash

    Sunday, July 23 2017 9:31 PM EDT2017-07-24 01:31:27 GMT

    PONDERAY, Idaho - Bonner County Emergency Management reports a multi-vehicle crash closed Highway 95 in both direction Sunday afternoon. The Bonner County Sheriff's Office reports the highway is closed at milepost 490 near Elmira Road, about 11 miles north of Ponderay, while investigators gather evidence and interview witnesses.

    More >>

    PONDERAY, Idaho - Bonner County Emergency Management reports a multi-vehicle crash closed Highway 95 in both direction Sunday afternoon. The Bonner County Sheriff's Office reports the highway is closed at milepost 490 near Elmira Road, about 11 miles north of Ponderay, while investigators gather evidence and interview witnesses.

    More >>
  • Kids open lemonade stand to celebrate mom who beat blood disorder

    Kids open lemonade stand to celebrate mom who beat blood disorder

    Sunday, July 23 2017 8:03 PM EDT2017-07-24 00:03:14 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - "Help Me Hayley" was contacted regarding a local family who has been through a rough couple of months. It's a story of children rallying around their mother to make a family dream come true. Meet Kandis Workman. She says she's been fighting a devastating blood disorder. The countless  appointments and treatments have taken a toll on her young family.

    More >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - "Help Me Hayley" was contacted regarding a local family who has been through a rough couple of months. It's a story of children rallying around their mother to make a family dream come true. Meet Kandis Workman. She says she's been fighting a devastating blood disorder. The countless  appointments and treatments have taken a toll on her young family.

    More >>