"Licensed Healthcare Professional" banned from courtroom - NBC Right Now/KNDO/KNDU Tri-Cities, Yakima, WA |

"Licensed Healthcare Professional" banned from courtroom

Posted: Updated:

It's day four in the trial of a Belt football player, suing Benefis for negligence after a devastating injury in 2014 left him a quadriplegic. 

Thursday morning in the courtroom, those in attendance saw two major themes happening even before lunchtime: credibility of evidence and experts, and use of the term "licensed healthcare professional."

University of Colorado neuroradiologist, Dr. David Rubenstein, took the stand to explain a handful of Robert Back's CT scans.  

He tried to discredit an illustration made by Benefis, showing Robert's brain from a vertical point of view... something Rubenstein says is impossible to do with a CT scan. 

But Benefis attorneys had a quick response, highlighting Rubenstein's qualifications and lack of experience in the surgery room. 

Rubenstein was just one of many witnesses to spark tension between the attorneys .

J.C. Weida is Head Athletic Trainer at the University of Montana. He repeatedly referred to himself, and the athletic trainer involved in the suit, Jessica Hansen, as 'licensed healthcare professionals," which is a term that's still being debated by attorneys and could help determine whether or not Hansen can be held legally responsible in Robert Back's injury. 

Until Judge Kutzman makes a decision on what exactly that term means and whether or not Jessica Hansen falls under it, he has banned the phrase from being used in the courtroom by the attorneys or the witnesses. The trial is scheduled to continue to Friday. 

HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Regional NewsMore>>

  • Kellogg recalls Honey Smacks because of salmonella potential

    Kellogg recalls Honey Smacks because of salmonella potential

    Friday, June 15 2018 10:43 AM EDT2018-06-15 14:43:14 GMT

    WASHINGTON - The Kellogg Company is voluntarily recalling some of its Honey Smacks cereal after salmonella infected 73 people in 31 states.    The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says most of the outbreaks were in California, Massachusetts, New York and Pennsylvania. The recall affects 15.3-ounce packages with the UPS Code 3800039103 and 23-ounce packages with the UPS Code 3800014810. 

    More >>

    WASHINGTON - The Kellogg Company is voluntarily recalling some of its Honey Smacks cereal after salmonella infected 73 people in 31 states.    The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says most of the outbreaks were in California, Massachusetts, New York and Pennsylvania. The recall affects 15.3-ounce packages with the UPS Code 3800039103 and 23-ounce packages with the UPS Code 3800014810. 

    More >>
  • Investigation into former fire captain began with Craigslist ad

    Investigation into former fire captain began with Craigslist ad

    Thursday, June 14 2018 7:19 PM EDT2018-06-14 23:19:05 GMT

    A former Benton County Fire Captain is spending three years in prison and once released will have ten years of probation and will have to register as a sex offender. 

    More >>

    A former Benton County Fire Captain is spending three years in prison and once released will have ten years of probation and will have to register as a sex offender. 

    More >>
  • UPDATE: Soap Lake Fire at 90% containment

    UPDATE: Soap Lake Fire at 90% containment

    Thursday, June 14 2018 1:35 AM EDT2018-06-14 05:35:12 GMT

    SOAP LAKE, Wash. - The Grant County Sheriff's Office has cancelled all evacuation notices for the Soap Lake Fire. At last update, the fire was still estimated to be approximately 2000 acres and 50 percent contained.

    More >>

    SOAP LAKE, Wash. - The Grant County Sheriff's Office has cancelled all evacuation notices for the Soap Lake Fire. At last update, the fire was still estimated to be approximately 2000 acres and 50 percent contained.

    More >>
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Search crews find body of missing rafter

    Search crews find body of missing rafter

    Monday, June 18 2018 12:26 AM EDT2018-06-18 04:26:44 GMT

    Rescue crews found a man’s body after a multi-agency search in Granite County.

    More >>

    Rescue crews found a man’s body after a multi-agency search in Granite County.

    More >>
  • Woman found dead on Phillips Street, man arrested

    Woman found dead on Phillips Street, man arrested

    Sunday, June 17 2018 5:29 PM EDT2018-06-17 21:29:33 GMT

    Missoula City Police say they were called to the area of Lowell School on Phillips Street around 2:26 Sunday morning for a report of an injured woman lying in the roadway. 

    More >>

    Missoula City Police say they were called to the area of Lowell School on Phillips Street around 2:26 Sunday morning for a report of an injured woman lying in the roadway. 

    More >>
  • Canoeist cross the country by water

    Canoeist cross the country by water

    Friday, June 15 2018 1:51 PM EDT2018-06-15 17:51:20 GMT
    It's a feat accomplished by only a select few. Our Bliss Zechman sits down with a pair of adventurous folks trying to make it from one coast to another in a  very unique way. 4,750 miles of paddling and portaging in 220 days. That's how far Martin Trahan  and Jillian Brown will have gone by the time their cross-oceanic journey ends. "Basically more people have walked on the moon than have done this route," said Brown.   The Canadian duo has moved through th...More >>
    It's a feat accomplished by only a select few. Our Bliss Zechman sits down with a pair of adventurous folks trying to make it from one coast to another in a  very unique way. 4,750 miles of paddling and portaging in 220 days. That's how far Martin Trahan  and Jillian Brown will have gone by the time their cross-oceanic journey ends. "Basically more people have walked on the moon than have done this route," said Brown.   The Canadian duo has moved through th...More >>
  • 2 people killed in deadly accident

    2 people killed in deadly accident

    Sunday, June 17 2018 12:46 PM EDT2018-06-17 16:46:27 GMT

    Two fatalities happen within the past 24 hours, one about 200 miles south of Great Falls. The Montana Highway Patrol is not releasing any information on that accident but according to their website it happened on Main Boulder road around 3:30 pm yesterday afternoon and is still being investigated. In Flathead County on Highway 93 near Olney. A driver was heading southbound when they drifted to the left of the highway. MHP said the driver then hit a driveway approach causing the vehic...

    More >>

    Two fatalities happen within the past 24 hours, one about 200 miles south of Great Falls. The Montana Highway Patrol is not releasing any information on that accident but according to their website it happened on Main Boulder road around 3:30 pm yesterday afternoon and is still being investigated. In Flathead County on Highway 93 near Olney. A driver was heading southbound when they drifted to the left of the highway. MHP said the driver then hit a driveway approach causing the vehic...

    More >>
  • Malfunction junction mend?

    Malfunction junction mend?

    Tuesday, June 12 2018 8:37 PM EDT2018-06-13 00:37:03 GMT
    The city of Helena is looking to reconstruct two chaotic five-point intersections. They're so chaotic, they've even earned the  term malfunction junction. No one has been hit in either area this year. However, long wait times encourage some people to jay walk. Plus, the cross walks can be very confusing.   "They aren't extremely dangerous right now because the amount of traffic. You aren't getting the high speeds that can come in there, but it is an obstruction to pede...More >>
    The city of Helena is looking to reconstruct two chaotic five-point intersections. They're so chaotic, they've even earned the  term malfunction junction. No one has been hit in either area this year. However, long wait times encourage some people to jay walk. Plus, the cross walks can be very confusing.   "They aren't extremely dangerous right now because the amount of traffic. You aren't getting the high speeds that can come in there, but it is an obstruction to pede...More >>
  • Montana river searched after person seen falling from bridge

    Montana river searched after person seen falling from bridge

    Searchers are combing the Yellowstone River in southern Montana after someone was seen falling from a bridge.More >>
    Searchers are combing the Yellowstone River in southern Montana after someone was seen falling from a bridge.More >>
  • Our Apologies

    The page you requested is currently unavailable. Pages on this site are constantly being revised, updated, and occasionally removed. You may have followed an outdated link or have outdated pages in your

    You have reached a page which is currently unavailable. We apologize for any inconvenience. Please use your browser's BACK button to return to the previous page

    More >>
  • Taylor Chase

    Taylor Chase

    Before she moved to Big Sky Country, Taylor worked as an investigative reporter at the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism.

    More >>

    Before she moved to Big Sky Country, Taylor worked as an investigative reporter at the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism.

    More >>
  • NewsMore>>

  • 57th Annual Montana 500 comes to Shelby

    57th Annual Montana 500 comes to Shelby

    Sunday, June 17 2018 8:13 PM EDT2018-06-18 00:13:27 GMT

    The 57th Annual Montana 500 Endurance Run for Model T's is starting up today as drivers from across the country gear up for the race in Shelby.  

    More >>

    The 57th Annual Montana 500 Endurance Run for Model T's is starting up today as drivers from across the country gear up for the race in Shelby.  

    More >>
  • Woman found dead on Phillips Street, man arrested

    Woman found dead on Phillips Street, man arrested

    Sunday, June 17 2018 5:29 PM EDT2018-06-17 21:29:33 GMT

    Missoula City Police say they were called to the area of Lowell School on Phillips Street around 2:26 Sunday morning for a report of an injured woman lying in the roadway. 

    More >>

    Missoula City Police say they were called to the area of Lowell School on Phillips Street around 2:26 Sunday morning for a report of an injured woman lying in the roadway. 

    More >>
  • Missing 5-year-old girl found safe

    Missing 5-year-old girl found safe

    Friday, June 15 2018 12:11 PM EDT2018-06-15 16:11:26 GMT

    Helena Police have issued a missing and endangered person advisory for 3-year-old Lyric Franklin. Lyric is an African American female. She was last seen wearing a pink shirt with "love" on the front and light colored shorts or a skirt. She also wears pink glasses. She is about three feet tall and weighs between 40 and 50 pounds. Lyric is suspected to be with her non-custodial father, Kielan Franklin. Kielan is an African American male, 5 foot 6 inches, and weighs about 250 ...

    More >>

    Helena Police have issued a missing and endangered person advisory for 3-year-old Lyric Franklin. Lyric is an African American female. She was last seen wearing a pink shirt with "love" on the front and light colored shorts or a skirt. She also wears pink glasses. She is about three feet tall and weighs between 40 and 50 pounds. Lyric is suspected to be with her non-custodial father, Kielan Franklin. Kielan is an African American male, 5 foot 6 inches, and weighs about 250 ...

    More >>
  • Grizzly bear dies from insecticides

    Grizzly bear dies from insecticides

    Thursday, June 14 2018 6:38 PM EDT2018-06-14 22:38:33 GMT

    Fish, Wildlife, and Parks have confirmed a young female grizzly bear died near Carter, a town between Fort Benton and Great Falls.

    More >>

    Fish, Wildlife, and Parks have confirmed a young female grizzly bear died near Carter, a town between Fort Benton and Great Falls.

    More >>
  • Luminaria Walk in Great Falls rescheduled

    Luminaria Walk in Great Falls rescheduled

    Thursday, June 14 2018 11:01 AM EDT2018-06-14 15:01:49 GMT
    Great Falls - Due to expected rain throughout the weekend the annual River's Edge Trail Luminaria Walk, as well as the Lewis & Clark Festival, have been rescheduled to August 25th. "The Lewis & Clark Festival and Luminaria Walk on August 25th will be the perfect kick-off for school beginning!" Becky Nelson wrote in a press release. The weather isn't keeping a few other events from happening this weekend. The Bluegrass in the Park Concert is still on for Friday, Ju...More >>
    Great Falls - Due to expected rain throughout the weekend the annual River's Edge Trail Luminaria Walk, as well as the Lewis & Clark Festival, have been rescheduled to August 25th. "The Lewis & Clark Festival and Luminaria Walk on August 25th will be the perfect kick-off for school beginning!" Becky Nelson wrote in a press release. The weather isn't keeping a few other events from happening this weekend. The Bluegrass in the Park Concert is still on for Friday, Ju...More >>
  • Victims identified in Great Falls shooting

    Victims identified in Great Falls shooting

    Tuesday, June 12 2018 9:40 PM EDT2018-06-13 01:40:55 GMT

    The Great Falls Police Department responded to reports of a disturbance and possible gunshots on the north side of town. One person in the area tells us that they saw two people being transported to the hospital but was not sure of the severity of their injuries. GFPD did confirm with us that two people were transported to Benefis but was later pronounced dead. Currently, GFPD is not searching for any suspects and they say that there is no threat to the community. We will keep ...

    More >>

    The Great Falls Police Department responded to reports of a disturbance and possible gunshots on the north side of town. One person in the area tells us that they saw two people being transported to the hospital but was not sure of the severity of their injuries. GFPD did confirm with us that two people were transported to Benefis but was later pronounced dead. Currently, GFPD is not searching for any suspects and they say that there is no threat to the community. We will keep ...

    More >>
  • Body found at Ryan Dam identified as Brittney Roberts

    Body found at Ryan Dam identified as Brittney Roberts

    Monday, June 11 2018 3:00 PM EDT2018-06-11 19:00:56 GMT

    GREAT FALLS  - At 4pm Monday a female body was recovered at Ryan Dam.  The body was found by Dam employees and recovered by Cascade County Sheriff's Office.  An autopsy is scheduled for Tuesday to determine the cause of death along with positive identification. Sheriff Bob Edwards says it is unclear at this time if this is the same woman who they've been looking for near the Black Eagle Dam. Click here for our previous coverage in the search efforts for Brittney Rober...

    More >>

    GREAT FALLS  - At 4pm Monday a female body was recovered at Ryan Dam.  The body was found by Dam employees and recovered by Cascade County Sheriff's Office.  An autopsy is scheduled for Tuesday to determine the cause of death along with positive identification. Sheriff Bob Edwards says it is unclear at this time if this is the same woman who they've been looking for near the Black Eagle Dam. Click here for our previous coverage in the search efforts for Brittney Rober...

    More >>
  • GFPS food truck is back for summer

    GFPS food truck is back for summer

    Sunday, June 17 2018 7:54 PM EDT2018-06-17 23:54:16 GMT

    Every year during the summer months, some kids in Great Falls go without a lunch, but starting Monday, the Great Falls Public School food truck will be out again to help fight this issue. 

    More >>

    Every year during the summer months, some kids in Great Falls go without a lunch, but starting Monday, the Great Falls Public School food truck will be out again to help fight this issue. 

    More >>